The OpenAI logo. Image: OpenAI (logo, public domain via Wikimedia Commons)

OpenAI says it found a recording device hidden in one of its offices, used its own AI models to work out where it had come from, and traced it to one of its engineers, who has since been fired and arrested by the FBI. The company announced the arrest on X on Tuesday evening, saying the employee had planted the device “a few days earlier”.

OpenAI didn’t name the employee or say which office was targeted. It said the FBI’s investigation is ongoing.

Hidden in toilet paper behind a TV

Fox News correspondent Bill Melugin posted an excerpt from the criminal complaint shortly afterwards. He named the man as Abdulrahman Alfozan, a Saudi national, and said he made his first appearance in federal court on Tuesday. The complaint refers to OpenAI only as “Company 1” and says Alfozan had worked there as an engineer since July 2025.

According to the excerpt, OpenAI staff found the device on or about September 30, “inserted into a USB port on the back of a television in an executive conference room” in one of its San Francisco buildings. It had been “concealed in toilet paper”, was installed on or about September 28, and its contents were encrypted, the complaint says.

Images from the complaint that Melugin shared show a small circuit board branded Seeed Studio, a maker of boards for hobbyist electronics, and a still from a motion-activated camera behind the screen, timestamped October 5, days after the device was found. Melugin says Alfozan was caught on OpenAI’s security cameras.

The Justice Department hasn’t published a press release, and the charges haven’t been made public. Alfozan hasn’t commented, and it isn’t known whether he has a lawyer. Nothing made public so far says who the recordings were meant for.

“No indications” anything was taken

OpenAI says it has “no indications” that the engineer accessed or took model weights, source code or customer data. It hasn’t said whether the device captured any conversations, or what was discussed in the room while it was there.

The case lands in a tense few weeks for OpenAI over who can get at its information. On October 1 it let three safety researchers go for allegedly sharing company information with an outside safety group, and the day before it accused people linked to China’s Moonshot AI of trying to copy its models’ hidden reasoning.

AI as the detective

OpenAI presents the case as proof of “how AI can help address these sophisticated security threats”, but says little about what its models did, beyond helping it “understand the device and where it had come from”. It hasn’t said which model it used, and the complaint’s mention of camera footage suggests ordinary security tools played a part too.

The pitch fits a wider argument in the industry about insiders. Microsoft’s Satya Nadella said last weekend that companies should treat AI models themselves as insider risks; here, OpenAI says a model helped catch a human one.

Update: Held without bail as prosecutors point to Saudi ties

Alfozan is charged with one count of using a device to intercept oral communications, under 18 U.S.C. § 2511(1)(b), which carries up to five years in prison and a $250,000 fine, according to the charging papers. He has not been charged with espionage, stealing trade secrets or acting as a foreign agent, and none of the allegations has been tested in court. In a detention memo filed on Oct 18, prosecutors said the investigation is ongoing and “may result in additional serious charges”.

The memo adds a good deal to the original complaint. Prosecutors say OpenAI security found a second, similar recording device on Oct 5 in a bag Alfozan had left in a printer room, and that photos on his iPhone show at least one more hidden recorder and the input panels of TVs in other OpenAI rooms, including another conference room used for sensitive meetings. They say he used an OpenAI productivity agent to find out which rooms executives used to meet “external partners”, and that OpenAI executives met government officials in the bugged room around the time the device was there.

The filing also describes frequent WhatsApp messages with a member of the Saudi royal family, as recently as Oct 5, who tried to recruit him to a Saudi AI initiative. In May, prosecutors say, that person wrote “Saudi needs you more then [sic] the US!” and Alfozan replied “100”. His wife and baby son flew to Doha the day after his arrest on a one-way business-class ticket that, according to the memo, was paid for by a Saudi military official. Prosecutors do not say the royal directed him to plant the device, and they set out two possible motives: helping his own business prospects or aiding a foreign government.

At a hearing on Oct 19, Magistrate Judge Alex Tse ordered Alfozan held without bail, saying there was a “significant” risk he would flee, CNBC reported from the courtroom. The Saudi Consulate in Los Angeles had offered to pay his full bail and promised not to issue him travel documents, which Tse called “problematic”:

It seems like a blank check: ‘We’re gonna pay whatever the court wants to make sure he gets out.’

Alex Tse, US magistrate judge

His lawyer, William Pernik, had asked for home detention with GPS monitoring and offered $1 million in assets, arguing that “nationality is not evidence of flight” and that the planned trip to Saudi Arabia was for “family and immigration reasons”. Fifty-four people wrote letters of support. Alfozan is due back in court on Nov 6.

Update: Indicted by a grand jury, with no new charges yet

A federal grand jury in San Francisco indicted Alfozan on Oct 27 on one count of intercepting oral communications, the same charge as in the complaint. The indictment says that from no later than Sept 28 until about Oct 5 he used a device on OpenAI’s premises to obtain information about its operations. It does not include the “additional serious charges” prosecutors had said the investigation might bring. The case, now 3:26-cr-00539, has been assigned to District Judge Vince Chhabria.

The indictment also names more hardware than earlier filings. Prosecutors want five Seeed Studio devices forfeited: the XIAO ESP32-S3 Sense recorder and its microSD card, the device seized from his bag on Oct 5, and three more taken from his home in Millbrae, California, on Oct 9. The penalty sheet still lists a maximum of five years in prison and a $250,000 fine, plus possible deportation. None of the allegations has been tested in court.

Update: Alfozan pleads not guilty

Alfozan pleaded not guilty to the single interception charge on Nov 6, Courthouse News reported from the hearing in San Francisco. He appeared before Magistrate Judge Peter Kang with his lawyer, David Rizk of Rizk & Shearer, and spoke only to give his name and age and to confirm he understood the charge. He remains in custody under the Oct 19 detention order, and no further charges have been filed. His next court date is Nov 17. Both sides declined to comment.

Update: Trial set for January as the judge presses prosecutors on spying claims

Alfozan will stand trial in January 2027 after asking for a speedy trial, US District Judge Vince Chhabria said at a status conference in San Francisco on Tuesday, November 17, Courthouse News reported from the courtroom. “The defendant has a right to a speedy trial, and if the defendant wants to go to trial in 60 days, we will do what we have to do to make it happen,” the judge said.

Alfozan’s lawyer, David Rizk, said the government had handed over too little evidence, and that he had seen nothing to support its suggestions that his client could also face charges of economic espionage, theft of trade secrets or acting as an unregistered foreign agent. Assistant US Attorney Nicholas Parker said 2,100 documents had been turned over, but that prosecutors still had to go through 160 hours of video that appears to show meetings at OpenAI, along with phones and laptops belonging to Alfozan and his wife. He doubted the January date would hold.

Chhabria said there seemed to be some pretty serious discovery violations and gave the government seven days to hand over all video and recordings, and all reports from the US Attorney’s Office, the FBI and other agencies involved. Parker conceded he knew of no evidence yet for the heavier charges, noting that the case was only five weeks old. The judge gave prosecutors the same seven days to file any such evidence, and warned:

If you made those assertions and are not yet aware of any evidence to support it, that is a real problem.

Judge Vince Chhabria, US District Court for the Northern District of California

Alfozan remains in custody. The judge gave no view on detention, and Rizk said he plans to ask a magistrate judge to reconsider it. The next hearing is on December 8.

Why it matters

AI labs guard model weights and plans worth billions, and a conversation in an executive meeting room can be as valuable as code. OpenAI has framed this as a win for AI-powered security, but the biggest questions are still open: what the device recorded, who it was for and whether more serious charges follow.

Sources: OpenAI Newsroom on X; Bill Melugin, Fox News, on X; US v. Alfozan, government detention memo (N.D. Cal.); US v. Alfozan, indictment (N.D. Cal.); CNBC; Courthouse News (plea, trial date).

Latest OpenAI news

More OpenAI news